Acoustic Samples: Listen to this Heatsink!

The Intel FCLGA4-S reference heatsink is pretty loud when its translucent 110mm diameter fan is spinning at the full 2900RPM in "P" Performance mode. The first acoustic sample illustrates the slow climb to full speed, the second is when the fan is set to "Q" quiet mode.

Finally, we use a PWM compatible fan speed controller to reduce RPMs to the lowest possible - a nice quiet 1000RPM. Quiet mode is easy to live with, but I think you'd drive yourself crazy after a few days with the FCLGA4-S heatsink running in "performance" mode.

To listen to this heatsink in operation, be sure to click on the little headphones icon below and play the sample MP3 files.

frostytech acoustic sampling chamber - full speed
	standard waveform view of a 10 second recording. click on the headphones icon to listen to an mp3 recording of this heatsink in operation. the fan is rotating at 2900 rpm with the switch set to performance (p) mode.

frostytech acoustic sampling chamber - quiet mode
	standard waveform view of a 10 second recording. click on the headphones icon to listen to an mp3 recording of this heatsink in operation. the fan is rotating at 2000 rpm with the switch set to quiet (q) mode.

frostytech acoustic sampling chamber - lowest speed
	standard waveform view of a 10 second recording. click on the headphones icon to listen to an mp3 recording of this heatsink in operation. the pwm fan is rotating at 1000 rpm, the slowest possible speed.

Sound Level Measurements: Which Heatsink is Quietest?

Listening to the actual noise a heatsink makes allows you to hear what pure numbers alone cannot get across. To further emphasize FrostyTech's reliance on cold hard facts when evaluating a heatsink, we also take noise level measurements with a sound level meter.

FrostyTech Heatsink Noise Level Measurements Noise level Decibel measurements of each heatsinks' fan in operation are taken with the aid of a sound level meter and sound isolating enclosure. The values may be higher than the mfgr's listed specs, but are directly comparable to one another. Measurements are made on the dB (A) scale, lower values are best. Information on Frostytech's test methodology is available here.
manufacturer:	model no.:	fan* speed:	noise level (dba):	cpu** platform
Scythe	Orochi SCORC-1000		27.8 dB	Intel/AMD
Scythe	Zipang		33.1 dB	Intel/AMD
Glacialtech	Igloo 5750 Silent		35.5 dB	Intel/AMD
Verax	Helado		36.3 dB	Intel/AMD
Intel	Stock Core 2 Duo		36.7 dB	Intel
Scythe	Mine Rev.B		36.8 dB	Intel/AMD
Scythe	Infinity SCINF-1000		37.8 dB	Intel/AMD
Scythe	Katana II		37.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Scythe	Shuriken	high	38.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Scythe	Andy Samuri Master SCASM-1000		38.4 dB	Intel/AMD
Scythe	Kama Cross		40.0 dB	Intel/AMD
Noctua	NH-U12P	high	40.7 dB	Intel/AMD
Asus	Triton 77	high	41.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Coolink	Silentator	high	41.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Scythe	Ninja Mini		41.7 dB	Intel/AMD
Noctua	NH-U9B	high	41.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Asus	Silent Square EVO	high	42.8 dB	Intel/AMD
Auras	SMF-660		43.4 dB	Intel
Glacialtech	Igloo 5710 Silent		43.4 dB	Intel/AMD
Coolermaster	Hyper48		43.6 dB	Intel/AMD
Auras	LPT-709		43.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Arctic Cooling	Alpine 7 Pro	high	44.1 dB	Intel
Thermalright	Ultra 120 Extreme		44.5 dB	Intel/AMD
Akasa	Revo (horizontal)	high	44.5 dB	Intel/AMD
Thermalright	SI-128SE		44.5 dB	Intel/AMD
Glacialtech	Igloo 5610 Silent		44.7 dB	Intel
Intel	FCLGA4-S Reference (1000rpm)	low	44.9 dB	Intel
Asus	Arctic Square	high	44.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Zalman	CNPS7000B-CU	high	44.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Glacialtech	Igloo 5062 Cu Light		45.2 dB	Intel
Noctua	NH-U12		45.4 dB	Intel/AMD
Coolermaster	Hyper 212		45.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Scythe	Shogun	high	45.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Rosewill	RCX-Z2-EX	high	45.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Scythe	Mugen		46.0 dB	Intel/AMD
Asus	Silent Knight 2	high	46.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Thermalright	MST-977SLE		46.5 dB	Intel
Intel	Stock Pentium D	high	47.5 dB	Intel
Coolermaster	Hyper Z600		47.7 dB	Intel/AMD
Akasa	AK-975CU	high	47.7 dB	Intel
nPowertek	TTIC NPH-1000		47.5 dB	Intel/AMD
3Rsystem	Iceage 120	high	47.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Zalman	CNPS8700 LED	high	48.1 dB	Intel/AMD
Akasa	AK-965	high	48.1 dB	Intel
Thermolab	TLI-U Nano Silencer		48.0 dB	Intel
Apack	CF900	high	48.3 dB	Intel
Apack	CF800	high	48.4 dB	Intel
LS Cable	SHS-T700		48.5 dB	Intel
Auras	CTC-868 (closed)		48.7 dB	Intel/AMD
Thermalfly	I75DUH		48.7 dB	Intel
Coolage	Frozen Orb F0-Z924AL	high	48.9 dB	Intel
Spire	SP601B3		48.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Apack	Zerotherm Nirvana 120		49.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Asus	Triton 75		49.6 dB	Intel/AMD
Zalman	CNPS7700-Cu LED	high	49.8 dB	Intel/AMD
nPowertek	NPH-775-1		50.1 dB	Intel
Xigmatek	HDT-S963	high	50.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Zalman	CNPS9500 LED	high	50.3 dB	Intel/AMD
Xigmatek	HDT-S1283	high	50.7 dB	Intel/AMD
Gigabyte	3D-Rocket		50.7 dB	Intel/AMD
Zalman	CNPS7700-Cu	high	50.7 dB	Intel/AMD
Zalman	CNPS7500-Cu LED	high	50.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Sunbeamtech	Core-Contact Freezer	high	51.3 dB	Intel/AMD
Alpha Novatech	PRE9060M92P	high	51.5 dB	Intel
Tuniq	Tower 120	high	51.6 dB	Intel/AMD
OCZ	Tempest		51.6 dB	Intel/AMD
Apack	Zerotherm BTF80		51.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Thermolab	TLI-S Micro Silencer		52.0 dB	Intel
Intel	FCLGA4-S Reference (Q mode 2000RPM)	low	52.1 dB	Intel
Apack	Zerotherm BTF90		52.1 dB	Intel/AMD
Cooljag	Falcon 92-AL	high	52.1 dB	Intel/AMD
Auras	LPT-700		52.2 dB	Intel
Auras	SLC-747	high	52.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Zalman	CNPS9700NT	high	52.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Glacialtech	Igloo 5750 PWM	high	52.3 dB	Intel/AMD
Xigmatek	HDT-S983	high	52.7 dB	Intel/AMD
OCZ	Vendetta	high	52.8 dB	Intel/AMD
Cooljag	Falcon 92-Cu	high	52.8 dB	Intel/AMD
SilenX	iXtrema IXC-120HA2	high	52.9 dB	Intel/AMD
Zalman	CNPS9500 AT		53.3 dB	Intel
Glacialtech	Igloo 5057 E		53.4 dB	Intel
Apack	Zerotherm BTF92 OC Ed	high	53.6 dB	Intel/AMD
Coolermaster	Hyper TX2		53.7 dB	Intel/AMD
Thermalright	Ultra 120		53.7 dB	Intel/AMD
Xigmatek	AIO-S80DP	high	55.0 dB	Intel/AMD
Verax	Quattro 1	high	55.4 dB	Intel/AMD
Cooljag	OAK-H2	high	55.6 dB	Intel
Cooljag	OAK-H	high	55.7 dB	Intel
Gigabyte	Volar GH-PSV21-FB	high	56.1 dB	Intel/AMD
Thermalright	Ultra-90	high	56.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Akasa	AK-960E		56.3 dB	Intel
Zalman	CNPS9700 LED	high	56.5 dB	Intel/AMD
Zalman	FS-C77		56.5 dB	Intel/AMD
Gigabyte	3D Rocket-Pro	high	56.7 dB	Intel/AMD
Xigmatek	HDT-SD964	high	57.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Zalman	CNPS8000	high	57.4 dB	Intel/AMD
EKL	V8	high	57.5 dB	Intel/AMD
Sunon	Waturbo		57.5 dB	Intel
Antazone	AS-C1000		57.6 dB	Intel/AMD
Noctua	NH-U9		58.4 dB	Intel/AMD
Rosewill	RCX-Z3	high	58.6 dB	Intel/AMD
Enzotech	Ultra-X	high	59.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Akasa	AK-920	high	59.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Coolermaster	Aquagate Mini R80	high	59.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Glacialtech	Igloo 5610 PWM	high	59.5 dB	Intel
Rosewill	RCX-Z2		59.9 dB	Intel
Spire	Fourier IV SP607B3-C		60.2 dB	Intel/AMD
Akasa	AK-922 (EVObue)	high	60.3 dB	Intel/AMD
Thermalfly	F1-IACSHA	high	60.4 dB	Intel/AMD
Akasa	AK-961		60.7 dB	Intel
Thermaltake	Jungle512	high	60.8 dB	Intel
Intel	FCLGA4-S Reference (P mode 2900RPM)	high	61.1 dB	Intel
Gigabyte	3D Cooler-Pro	high	62.5 dB	Intel/AMD
Gigabyte	3D Cooler-Ultra	high	63.0 dB	Intel/AMD
Evercool	PT02-9232CP		63.3 dB	Intel
nPowertek	SF 775-2	high	64.6 dB	Intel
Gigabyte	GH-PCU23-VE	high	65.6 dB	Intel/AMD
ASUS	Starice	high	67.4 dB	Intel/AMD
Thermalfly	I75DUB	high	68.5 db	Intel
Gigabyte	G-Power Pro	high	71.9 dB	Intel/AMD
			noise level (dba)
*unless noted, for reference heatsinks with variable-speed fans only the 'high speed' (12V) fan noise measurement is included in the comparison sheet; more detailed results for the low fan speed (~5V) tests reside in each specific heatsink review. ** 'AMD' denotes compatibility with socket 754/939/940 & AM2 processors where applicable. 'Intel' denotes compatibility with socket 775 platform.

Acoustic samples are all well and good, but sound level measurements provide the clearest picture for drawing comparisons. With its 110mm diameter fan spinning at full speed in "Performance" mode, the Intel FCLGA4-S reference heatsink creates a noisy racket - 61.1 dBA. In "Quiet" mode the noise output drops dramatically, to 52.1 dBA. The lowest possible fan speed is 1000RPM, and in situations where the motherboard BIOS can drop the PWM's fan speed that low, expect noise of about 44.9 dBA. The Zalman ZM-MFC2 PWM fan speed controller was used to monitor fan RPM for the final low speed test.

Next up, Intel thermal test platform results...